Wayfair vs Overstock
Whether you've just moved into your new home or have lived in your favorite area for years, there is always opportunity for new items, refreshed décor, and distinctive style.
There are several stores that focus on certain styles, but the reality is that most of us decorate with a mix of items from various styles to create a unique house.
Fortunately, Wayfair and Overstock provide a diverse selection of art deco, coastal, and modern décor and furniture to help you decorate your house exactly as you like. You'll also find some really good offers, which I'll go into later.
First, in this Wayfair vs Overstock comparison, I'll look at the origins of each business to offer you some context.
Wayfair was launched in 2002 by Steven Conine and Niraj Shah. The two met after taking an entrepreneur training and discovering that there was a market for a diverse assortment of furnishings.
The business debuted online in 2011 and swiftly gained traction. It is currently a family of five brands, including Wayfair, AllModern, and Birch Lane.
With the conviction that "everyone should have a home they love," the business is dedicated to supplying furnishings for houses everywhere, making it easier to find, order, and receive pieces.
Buyers may shop all of their favorite brands in one location, with an infinite choice of pieces and a diverse range of brands. The business is based in Boston, Massachusetts, and operates warehouses in the United States, Canada, Germany, and the United Kingdom, providing worldwide shipping at rates as low as the cost.
Overstock was established in 1999 by Patrick Michael Byrne, initially as a method of selling house furnishings inventory at extremely low prices from bankrupt businesses.
Today, buyers can find those same prices, but the selection includes overstocked goods from well-known companies worldwide.
The business is headquartered in Utah and ships worldwide to over 180 countries with the goal of "making beautiful and comfortable houses accessible by assisting consumers in easily and confidently finding exactly what they want for less. "
If you're reading this Wayfair vs Overstock review, you're probably having difficulties deciding which brand is the greatest fit for you.
Fortunately, I will walk you through all of the details of each company, including their product selections, quality, price and value, client testimonials, and more, allowing you to start decorating your home with items you enjoy.
Wayfair Hoboken 38” Wide Tufted Armchair vs Overstock Lenola Contemporary Upholstered Accent Arm Chair Review:
These accent chairs are ideal for anybody who enjoys modern patterns and bright hues. They are both functional and visually appealing, featuring thick cushions and beautiful tones of blue. Let's compare them:
Wayfair Hoboken 38-inch Tufted Armchair:
- Jean blue (with five additional color options)
- Tufted seat and back
- Solid wood frame.
- Tapered midcentury legs.
- Dimensions: 31" high, 38" broad
Overstock Lenola Modern Upholstered Accent Arm Chair:
- Velvet navy blue (three additional colour choices)
- Unique cut-out armrest design with cushion backing.
- Sturdy metal frame.
- Gold geometrical legs
- 27" tall, 34" wide.
If you like a one-of-a-kind accent chair, either of these options may be ideal for you (provided the proportions fit your space).
It all depends on the fabric you choose, whether it's Overstock's silky smooth velvet or Wayfair's soft canvas. They also have their own special touches if you prefer traditional tufts or want some contemporary, geometric forms and cutouts.
Wayfair Imel Frame Coffee Table With Storage vs Overstock Copper Grove Cranesbill XBase Coffee Table Review:
Every living room should have a coffee table, but that does not mean you have to accept uninteresting designs and subpar finishes. Fortunately, both companies provide a diverse selection of coffee tables to provide functionality and flair to your living room.
Let's explore a few more alternatives that might perform nicely in a variety of locations.
Wayfair Imel Frame Coffee Table With Storage:
- Modern, geometric shape.
- Glass tabletops
- The frame is available in brass, nickel, white, or black finish.
- Second-tier storage
- Dimensions: 17" H x 45" L x 20" W.
Overstock Copper Grove Cranesbill Coffee Table with X-base:
- Farmhouse style, with an Xcutout on the sides.
- Solid MDF table top
- Nine distinct color choices to match your décor.
- Second-tier storage.
- 18" H x 39. 2" L x 21. 7" W.
While both coffee tables are neutral and will fit nicely in any room, your particular design taste may impact your decision. They both have a basic rectangular form, but the color possibilities and intriguing details distinguish them as excellent selections for any house.
Wayfair Timmothy Geometric Shag Gray Area Rug vs Overstock Newton Moroccan Shag Trellis Moroccan Area Rug Review:
Rugs may make or break a room by providing a neutral, grounding element, a vibrant burst of color, or feeling out of place with the rest of the design.
Fortunately, both brands provide a large assortment of rugs to match your home exactly, but let us look at some more neutral options that would look great in any area.
Wayfair Timothy Geometric Shag Gray Area Rug:
- Sizes include 2'x3' and 11'x15'.
- There are four color options: gray, cream, blue, and green.
- Cohesive geometrical trellis diamond pattern.
- Machinemade of polypropylene
Overstock Newton Moroccan Shag Trellis Moroccan Area Rug:
- Sizes range from 2'x2'11'' to 12'x15'.
- There are three color options: gray, cream, and blue.
- Geometric trellis pattern with variation in shape
- Machine-made from polypropylene.
These neutral, bohemian-style rugs will bring warmth to your home with their fluffy texture and basic designs.
The delicate weave is excellent for stepping onto when you get out of bed, or as a warm entrance into your home office or living area. The fibers are also extremely durable, able to withstand dogs and a lot of foot activity.
Wayfair vs Overstock: Quality
Nothing is more frustrating than believing you're getting a great bargain only to learn that the quality is lacking, leaving you with a veneer-peeling coffee table and a rug that never stops shedding.
Fortunately, for this Wayfair versus Overstock review, I discovered that both companies are dedicated to delivering excellence in every way, including performance, attractiveness, sustainability, and cost!
Wayfair offers over 5,000 brands in all categories and styles, allowing you to complete your home.
Nonetheless, the business promotes ethical sourcing practices by requiring suppliers to adhere to strict human rights, labor, and environmental safeguards throughout their procurement and production processes.
The 'Shop Sustainably' option makes it simple to locate businesses who are open about their sourcing and production.
The packing and procedures are constantly reviewed to find methods to reduce the carbon footprint, utilize recycled materials, and produce less trash in general.
Overstocked items you'll find at Overstock are not defective; they're simply not selling at the pace that businesses want them to sell and are all brand new.
According to the company, all fair trade goods are delivered carbon neutral, although there are few options for minimizing waste and ensuring ethical sourcing.
Since neither company creates the things it sells, determining the overall quality of the items without some consumer input is challenging.
I saw several pleased consumers who were able to complete their rooms with goods that were reasonably priced in comparison to how lovely they were, but I will go into the price and worth in further detail later.
Overall, both companies appear to provide excellent items at reasonable prices. However, Wayfair is a little more forthright about buying ethically. However, Overstock prices are normally a little lower, so it depends on how much you want to spend!
Wayfair vs Overstock: Price & Value
We all fantasize about the days when we would be designing our houses, saving inspiration on Pinterest for all of the various rooms in our future homes and the styles we want to keep in mind.
But then that day arrives, and you walk into the shop to discover that a single throw pillow costs $30, shattering your dreams.
Fortunately, as I said in this Wayfair vs Overstock review, both companies provide cheap prices, allowing you to save money on décor for yourself and make your aspirations a reality.
However, I'm here to figure out which brand is the best value for your money, so let's look at those price tags.
Wayfair:
- Hoboken 38" Wide Tufted Armchair: On sale for $279, reduced from $459.
- Imel Frame Coffee Table with Storage: On sale for $185, regularly $300.
- Timmothy Geometric Shag Gray Area Rug: $47$819 on sale from $59$1148, depending on size.
Overstock:
- Lenola Modern Upholstered Accent Chair: $279 on sale from $319
- Copper Grove Cranesbill Coffee Table: $106 on sale from $126.
- Newton Moroccan Shag Trellis Moroccan Area Rug: $33$703 on sale for $75$1635, depending on size.
Wayfair's prices vary greatly, so you can always discover something that fits your budget.
The same is true for Overstock, although prices are typically lower because the items are overstocked and sold at wholesale prices. Finding what you need is simplified even further because you can sort products from the lowest to the highest price, or vice versa.
While both companies are dedicated to offering high-quality products, the nature of Overstock products may make it more difficult to find matching pieces in the future.
If you require four seats right now but may need an additional two in a year, Wayfair may be a better option for you to find them again.
While the sale prices are similar, the original prices for each item of furniture differ. Wayfair is normally somewhat more pricey.
So, if you come across a piece on sale, Wayfair may be the finest place to shop because you will save a little more. Overstock often has cheaper starting prices than other retailers if what you want isn't on sale.
Wayfair vs Overstock: What do Customers Think?
I've addressed practically all you need to know about both brands, including comparisons of some of their best-selling items, total pricing, and value. But are they truly worth all of the hype?
In this Wayfair vs Overstock review, I'll find out. I've gotten client testimonials from Consumer Affairs, Trustpilot, and SiteJabber. First, let's compare the two brands' ratings:
Wayfair:
Consumer Affairs: 2. 2/5 stars from 590 reviews.
SiteJabber: 1. 78/5 stars based on 1,397 reviews.
Trustpilot: 1. 4/5 stars based on 3,010 reviews
Overstock:
Consumer Affairs: 3. 4/5 stars based on 941 reviews.
SiteJabber: 3. 26/5 stars based on 1,671 reviews
Trustpilot: 1. 3/5 stars based on 1,659 reviews.
Both companies have a terrible reputation on Trustpilot, which I believe is somewhat unjust since both are quick to provide answers. Nonetheless, let's look at some of the highlights from the comments for both brands.
Wayfair:
- Easy-to-use app and website
- High-quality pieces
- Exceptional customer support
- Easy to personalize parts with several color and size options
- There are several products and styles to select from.
Like many others, one customer considers herself a repeat buyer because of her great experiences with both the goods and the pricing, stating:
"Decorated my whole house through Wayfair. I have to say, I was hesitant about ordering online, but Wayfair made it not just simple, but I was able to stay within my budget and the items bought were of excellent quality/buy!
Another customer commended the outstanding customer service:
"I genuinely believe Wayfair deserves credit in leaps and bounds since my husband and I have been purchasing so much from them to decorate our new house. First, there is the issue of their customer support crew. We purchase by phone and have encountered some of the kindest individuals on the planet. "
They add that "they go above and beyond to accommodate. " We are always pleased with every item because they are all of the highest quality. We adore Wayfair and believe they deserve credit for being a fantastic firm! "
Overstock:
- Daily Deals
- Simple and user-friendly website.
- Attentive customer service.
- There is a wide selection of exceptional and unique items to select from.
- Affordable pricing.
One user praises the website's design, quick customer service, and excellent products:
"Overstock.com is one of the greatest sites I recently purchased a new house and ordered a lot of items through them I had a issue with two of them and they worked with me until I got those products which I really do appreciate so far everything I've ordered is exactly as it says and appears on that website. "
Complaints with both brands are common related to shipment problems, such as damaged merchandise or sluggish delivery speeds. Both companies use ordinary carriers, hence this is not something to expect.
However, they each provide remedies to ensure that the client is satisfied with the result, including item replacements, vouchers, and entire refunds. One shopper explains their relationship with the carrier and the brand clearly:
"We just ordered a bathroom sink and vanity from Overstock.com. When it arrived, I saw Fedex drop it off their truck onto the pavement! Needless to say, the vanity was destroyed! To cut a long story short, Overstock provided us with a replacement right away when we notified them!! "
Overall, Wayfair receives poorer reviews, but the total number of reviews is fewer, implying that the comment pool is smaller. Regardless, the brand's customer support is excellent, attempting to resolve any concerns as soon as possible.
With both companies, you can expect excellent quality for the price, and it is evident that this quality extends beyond the products themselves.
Who Will You Shop With?
In this Wayfair versus Overstock review, I discovered that the two companies have several similarities, both being excellent destinations to purchase for discounts on beautiful and functional home things. However, there are several important distinctions that may influence your decision.
Wayfair has a broader selection of items and brands, and appears to give larger discounts, however Overstock prices are cheaper to begin with. When searching for a deal, it really depends on the day, and you may discover a better one on either site!
Wayfair is more explicit about its sustainability initiatives, while Overstock provides details on its aim to reduce its carbon impact.
However, the latter provides considerably quicker shipping times, as well as free shipping on all purchases. So, if you're ready to wait, Wayfair may be the better option for you, but if you want to decorate immediately, choose Overstock.
Overall, both brands are an excellent choice for saving money on your next home project. So, having navigated through this Wayfair vs. Overstock review, I only have one question: which website will you visit first?
